PA AI failures

An attorney in Dubinin v. Papazian filed a brief with ten AI-fabricated citations, ending the case

In Dubinin v. Papazian, plaintiff's counsel Missiva Tilleli Khacer filed a response brief containing at least ten fabricated case citations and quotations attributed to nonexistent Eleventh Circuit opinions. The drafting had been delegated to New York attorney Nataliya Gavlin, whose legal assistant used generative AI to produce the brief. The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida dismissed the case without prejudice, ordered Khacer to pay $4,030.90 in defendant's attorneys' fees, and referred all counsel to the Florida Bar and the court's Grievance Committee.

Confidence

High (multi-source, primary)